The following list has been compiled of the different teachers on the island. There were many changes and it is not necessarily complete.
| Period / Date | Teacher |
| c1830 | Thomas Drever(?) |
| 1841 | James Harcus, Doggerboat |
| 1851 | William Harcus, Doggerboat |
| 1861 | David Drever, Windywa |
| 1881 & 1891 | James Harcus, Hammar |
| Feb 1893 - Oct 1894 | Jessie Marwick |
| Nov 1894 | James Harcus (asked to officiate for a short time) |
| Mar 1895 | Jane Paterson |
| Sep 1896 - Oct 1898 | Cecilia Inkster |
| Feb 1899 - Oct 1899 | James Hill(?) |
| Nov 1899 - May 1900 | Maggie Jane Anderson |
| Feb 1901 - Aug 1901 | William McCallum |
| Dec 1901 | David Crombie |
| Apr 1902 | Mary Kirkness |
| May 1903 | Margaret G Work |
| Feb 1904 - Apr 1904 | Mathe W Wards |
| May 1904 | Williejohn Berlin Gilmour |
| Dec 1904 - Jan 1906 | Annie J Logie |
| Apr 1906 - Dec 1906 | Jane Sutherland |
| Jan 1907 | Lilias Brims Sutherland |
| Feb 1907 - Nov 1907 | Florence Falconer |
| Apr 1908 - Jul 1910 | Lizzie Tulloch (former pupil of Eday South School) |
| Oct 1910 - Apr 1912 | Miss Stickler(?) |
| May 1912 | Adeline M J Harcus |
| Dec 1912 | Mary Jane Harcus |
| Apr 1914 | M I Harcus |
| Jan 1915 - Mar 1915 | Unknown |
| Aug 1916 - Feb 1919 | M I Seatter (being Mary Isabella Harcus, daughter of former teacher James Harcus) |
| Oct 1919 - Sep 1921 | Grace Sinclair |
| Dec 1921 - 1923 | Emma B Mathieson |
| 1923 - Sep 1926 | Millie J Leslie |
| Oct 1926 - 1928 | Margaret A Sutherland |
| 1928 - Jan 1930 | Margaret J Matheson |
| Jan 1930 - 1931 | Jessie Harper |
| Aug 1931 - Feb 1940 | Annie J Rousay who married Jock Harcus, Doggerboat |
| May 1940 - Jan 1946 | Mary E Tulloch who married Balfour Rendall, Windywa |
| Jan 1946 - Jul 1946 | George Simpson |